History, especially ancient desert and medieval history, abounds with myths and legends such as Hermes and the Philosopher’s Stone, Glastonbury Abbey, the Holy Grail, Merlin, King Arthur and the treasure of the Templars, just to name a few…and then there is the legend of the Cathar Treasure.
In my previous post wherein I introduced the subject of this medieval religious sect, I noted their propensity for eschewing trappings of the mundane world. This rejection was based on their belief that the physical world and their incarnation in it was not a creation of God but rather a creation of Satan. In adopting this belief, the dedicated Cathars, known as Parfaits, not only rejected the idea of procreation, but they also did not partake in the consumption of any food which was a result of procreation. As material acquisitions for their own needs were kept to a bare minimum, it begs the question, ‘how did the legend of a Cathar Treasure arise’?
According to author and Cathar historian, Zoe Oldenburg, by the end of the twelfth century, the Cathar movement of the Languedoc had amassed a considerable fortune. To begin with, the majority of Parfaits were men of substance who turned over their property to the church. In addition, there were also credentes, ‘rank and file’ members, who left legacies of their entire fortunes to the church. And, while living, many credentes made generous donations of cash, land, houses and even chateaux. While the Parfaits never broke their vow of poverty according to Oldenburg, they accepted all donations which were then put to the best use in the interests of the church.
As a Community, the Cathars were known for providing support to the poor and those in need in the cities and surrounding countryside. They maintained communes which incorporated schools, monasteries and hospitals. Furthermore they founded working craft guilds, particularly in the art of weaving which not only provided product but also functioned as an educational training ground for the young and ‘novitiates.’
While such amassing of property and goods certainly would be considered a ‘treasure,’ references to ‘The Cathar Treasure’ often imply that it was something of far more importance and legend such as the Holy Grail… which of course has never been found. Speculative circumstances surrounding the Treasure’s disappearance often tell of it having been hidden some two months prior to the fiery execution of two hundred-plus Parfaits on March, 1244 at Montseguer. Possessing the secret of the Treasure’s hiding place, three Parfaits and another man, possibly a mountain guide, escaped the flames on the night of March 16 by repelling down the side of Montsegur’s pog. The men then hid in caves protecting the secret and were never discovered.
Oldenburg surmises that the Cathar cache consisted of goods for trading as well as gold and silver coins; this certainly makes sense given the atmosphere of persecution and brutality of the times. However, perhaps even more precious to the Cathars was that for them, the Treasure consisted of their most sacred books and writings which were critical in helping maintain allegiance to their dogma and tradition. This possibility makes even more sense as literature in the early middle ages onward, was considered as precious as gold in many cases. Whatever the truth is, to this day the location and substance of the Cathars’ Treasure remains a mystery.
Caves with Secrets
Photography©Gaye F. Mack, Inc.
You can follow me on:
https://www.facebook.com/gayemackauthor, https://www.twitter.com/gayemack, https://www.plus.google.com or https://www.linkedin.com
the cather treasure, is it a physical treasure or a way of life? that is the question. would a physical treasure cause such fear and loathing, murder and mayhem? i think not….
thanks for commenting! I would agree with you…the ‘treasure’ was far deeper than anything material which is a main theme of the current book I’m working on. I don’t doubt they held sacred texts as well, particularly as some legends claim an unofficial version of St. John known only to a few of the Perfects…but the real treasure was something entirely different and of a spiritual nature. It hardly seems reasonable that 3 or 4 Cathars would have risked their lives down the side of that Pog(which is not for the faint of heart by the way) to protect gold,etc. particularly since the Cathars weren’t into material goods…certainly they used such things to aid those in need but something considered treasure by them had to be far more important to their legacy…
I was told recently that a baby was lowered and was ‘the treasure’ have you ever heard mention of this? The reality of the Cathars touches me deeply…
Maria, hello…well the Cathar story is fascinating and one that I’ve studied for about 30 years…however, I’ve never read either in contemporary or scholarship writings the the treasure was in the form of a baby…there have been many speculations as to what the treasure was…material goods such as gold, silver, etc seem unlikely as the Cathars weren’t into possessions…and of course there is always the theory that it was ‘the grail’…however my feeling is that the ‘treasure’ was probably sacred knowledge as I say below in another reply…there is speculation that a small circle of Perfects possessed a special version of St. John’s Gospel …which, if true, makes sense to me as it would have been considered a Treasure to those who survived the massacre at Montsegur in 1244…Unfortunately, while several literary agents found my Cathar book of interest, they were hesitant to take it on because of the narrow historical fiction market currently in play…if you’re interested in a fascinating look at the Cathars, I’d suggest, “The Cathar View” from Polair publishing .. https://www.polairpublishing.co.uk
you can get it on amazon!
Very interesting topic! I think the cathar treasure was a stone. In Eschenbach’s version of the grail story, the holy grail is a stone that fell from heaven. I am convinced that the Cathar elite were the ones that actually wrote the grail stories to hide a great secret. It can’t be a coincidence that all three grail stories were written between 1190-1210, which is only a few years after the inquisition was created. The four grail hallows were the cup, a spear, a sword and a dish. According to Jessie Weston these elements of the grail stories originated in eyewitness accounts of initiation ceremonies. So I do believe the Cathar treasure is in fact the holy grail (a stone).